Earlier this year, the penultimate episode of Live deadThe ninth season brought us one of most shocking, heart-breaking moments in the history of the series. Tonight's troubled lead to the midseason finals came as a tragic surprise, but the real blow is one of show worst episodes for quite some time.
Although Open Your Eyes is not good, it is not bad at all. Much of it is fine, and there are still some nice storytelling and some great character moments scattered throughout. Like the whole of this half-season, Siddiqui (Avi Nash) it is still shrouded in guilt for survival whispers " the massacre, but now he is specifically mourning the murder of his former medical specialist Enid. R.Ember as the whisperers kept his eyes open and forced him to watch Alfa kill him? It gives his PTSD focus scenes a miss, which is good because he has a lot of them in this episode.
Even better, Siddiqui's current nervous breakdown is embedded in the narrative, so they are not just the same reminder he witnessed some horrific events last season. When Carroll and Darryl make their whisper, one very upset Gabriel – justifiably unfortunate that they made such a big decision without the approval of the city council and potentially annoyed Alpha once again – demands that the prisoner's wounds be healed, though Carroll very much wants to to torment him. Siddique tries to help Whisperer, but gets retrospective immediately, so Dr. Dante (Juan Javier Cardenas) it handles instead.
Carroll asks Lydia the best way to get answers from someone who is essentially one of the cults of Alpha, Lydia responds by showing Alexandria what she can provide, that this way of life can survive – because if that idea can to return to the rest of the cult, it will spread. So, Carol offers the prisoner toast and jam, which he quickly spits into her Face Torture begins almost immediately, but quickly ends when Carroll discovers the whispers that Alpha killed her daughter and realizes that if they learn of the living Lydia and that Alpha has lied and ignored her own law, the cult is likely to fall apart.
Unfortunately, the prisoner mysteriously begins to cough up blood and dies shortly before Lydia is brought. When Siddiqui examines the body, he discovers that Dante has given the prisoner poisonous hemocell pills instead of some more useful, less fatal drug. It's pretty dubious, but Dante has a solid excuse: He assumed the pills were something else because Siddique packed the sack of drugs they would bring to treat the man originally – and Dante could not imagine that Siddiqui would bring poison first. place.
Given that Sidic has barely slept all season and that his retrospectives continue to get worse and more detailed, that is an extremely reasonable explanation…but it is difficult to completely break the Dante-shaped warning flag once it is raised. So it's not the biggest shock when at the end of the episode, Siddiqui – who, fortunately, finally realizes that the water in the city is making everyone sick – has another huge retrospective on the massacre and realizes that Dr. Dante Pocket has kept his eyes on it. open and they both fight.
To learn that Dante was the man inside Alpha is not particularly shocking, given that he has been alternately nasty since then his first appearanceand moreover, he is the only new character in Alexandria. What shocked me is that he was killing Sidic. Not because I didn't expect Dante to try, but because after Carl's death and Rick's kidnapping and massacre last season and the imminent departure of Michano, Siddique by default became one of the biggest characters on the show, even though he only arrived in the eighth season. I understand that's why Siddic was chosen, but man, I seriously don't know how many more main characters the show can lose at this point.
To her credit, Live dead does he manage things so cleverly that Siddiqui's murder is as tragic as possible, first by making sure he has a repetitive scene with PSTD in almost every episode, making sure the character stays in the minds of viewers all season ( a smaller version of how season nine spent so much time focusing on Henry, too, to maximize the impact of his death). The play also reminds us that Siddic and Rosita had a child, and even Rosita saved Siddiqu's life by rescuing her from drowning after being thrown into a small reservoir in the city, after a particularly bad flashback.
Rosita then gives him a sensible talk about how Siddiqui will deal with him because he is not alone, echoed later by Dante's greatly affected speech on how Siddiqui should not blame himself for not understanding the water was spoiled earlier, that they were together in this, and that Siddiqui was Dante's friend. Siddiqui realizes that Dante is a whisperer right after this, which should give Dante his main words. Instead, Dante cries “I didn't want this! Not you! "Because he suffers life from someone he truly considers a friend.
The scene is there real emotional impact…but things will start to fall apart once the loans are fulfilled. Dante first appeared in season 10 premiere, which means he arrived after the massacre and after the Fisher had already secretly walked among the colonists. Why wasn't everyone completely suspicious of him? How the hell did he get information in Alpha without anyone noticing something? And if Alpha had an inside man all the time, why the devil needs Gamma to find out how many people live in Alexandria from Aaron?
Speaking of which, Aaron continued meeting with Gamma, though he luckily knows he is there to get information from him. (This still does not explain Aaron's complete reversal of Whisperer's furious grudge to anyone who wants to have a friendly conversation with them during this half-season.) Aaron is following Lydia's advice from the beginning of the episode, not that he was there to hear it. He talks to Gamma about Alexandria, how good there are, how many kids are safe (well, as safe as anyone Live dead), including one of their own. When Gamma inadvertently discovers she has a sister, Aaron tries to reconnect with her, saying she has lost a brother. Gamma is upset – mainly because she deliberately feeds her sister on the zombiesrun away, and are a cat from Alpha to fill her cult juice.
Later, she meets Aaron again, seeking answers that he still has absolutely no reason to give her, when Carol a lot accidentally drive with Lydia in tow. Carol is determined to show someone in the whispers that Lydia was alive to sow the seeds of discord and could not find a better candidate for discovery Alpha broke her own rules and left her daughter to live by following the same rule and killing her sister. Gamma escapes, there is a very understandable cry while Lydia– Who gets very upset when she realizes that Carol used her just like her mother used to – she runs away and goes solo. (This always seems like a stupid move TWD, but Lydia's decision makes more sense when you remember that most of Alexandria hate her, so there's honestly not much reason to go back.)
Although Carol Egg Machine is not great on stage, the real problem is returning to Dante. Lydia is right in saying that Alexandria's existence will make many whisperers realize that they can have a life that does not include wearing masks made of dead people. Alpha specifically stated that she wanted to destroy the colony so that her people were not tempted by it, and that is exactly what happened to Lydia. So why Dante, who is not so cultured that he can pass for incredibly normal, if a little sunny friend for months, and who lives that sweet Alexandrian life for those same months, still in the Whisperer Team? And, for that matter, how the devil Lydia never recognized Dante?
Just…it's just chaos and it's cheaper than Siddiqui's death, despite the episode – and the season – otherwise solid attempts to make it important. But there is something really heart-warming about this being just the second bad episode of the show's New Era, and even then, these problems aren't nearly as great as the issues in the show were before. That's just because Live dead it was so good that the nonsense in this episode feels so disappointing. I mean, if "Open Your Eyes" aired somewhere in season eight, it would honestly be one of the best episodes we've had in years.
- The episode that opened about a hundred shots of Sidik giving water to sick patients was little, but I appreciated every shot in the form of the evil dead on the chair and hands coming from nowhere to grab it.
- Live dead it's not a sexy show, so let's all try to appreciate the look of Darryl's shirt. Of course, he's covered in Batman-style scars, probably from abuse of his father and brother.
- Man, you don't get paid to be a doctor in this series. Denise, Enid, now Siddiqui – and Dante's no chance of being long for this world, even if he can somehow hide it Sidik's death.
- Hey, where the devil is Gamma's nephew now? Earl and Themes got the baby last season after Gamma's sister was forced to leave, but then Thames broke up. I can't imagine that old Earl is dealing with a father.
- Aaron gave Gamma one of his child's drawings honestly it's one of the weirdest things I've ever seen on this show. Not bad, exactly, it's just total nonsense.
- Before he dies, Siddiqui gives credit where he likes the loan. "I checked some tips for his babies," he told Rosita. "Poor chart – that shit was accurate. Literally! Eugene is a sincere scribe. "Thank goodness, they weren't his last words, or his death would have been completely tragically.
For more, make sure you don't follow us on Instagram @io9dotcom.